Saturday, 31 January, 2009

The Misesian Case against Keynes

By Hans-Hermann Hoppe, via the Mises Institute:

I – Classical Economic Theory
It is my goal to reconstruct some basic truths regarding the process of economic development and the role played in it by employment, money, and interest. These truths neither originated with the Austrian school of economics nor are an integral part of only this tradition of economic thinking.
In fact, most of them were part and parcel of what is now called classical economics, and it was the recognition of their validity that uniquely distinguished the economist from the crank. Yet the Austrian school, in particular Ludwig von Mises and later Murray N. Rothbard, has given the clearest and most complete presentation of these truths (Mises [1949] 1966; Rothbard [1962] 1970). Moreover, that school has presented them their most rigorous defense by showing them to be ultimately deducible from basic, incontestable propositions (such as that man acts and knows what it means to act) so as to establish them as truths whose denial would not only be factually incorrect but, much more decisively, would amount to logical contradictions and absurdities.
[1]
I will first systematically reconstruct this Austrian theory of economic development. Then I will turn to the "new" theory of J.M. Keynes, which belongs, as he himself proudly acknowledged, to the tradition of "underworld" economics (like mercantilism) and of economic cranks like S. Gesell (Keynes 1936). I will show that Keynes's new economics, like that "underworld" tradition, is nothing but a tissue of logical falsehoods reached by means of obscure jargon, shifting definitions, and logical inconsistencies intended to establish a statist, anti-free-market economic system.

Read the rest here.

6 comments:

Eowyn said...

The problem with Keynes is he liked to pigeon-hole worker behavior in standardized format, such that they must inhabit his "macro equals micro" format. In essence, they become cut-and-dried, reliably crunchable numbers -- not human beings, with all the variables that come therewith.

The author of the piece you've shared pretty much blows that out of the water by showing workers have CHOICES (not accounted for by Keynes), and act on them.

Bravo, Walk-Man. Good stuff.

Eowyn said...

P.S. Keynes was an ardent advocate of eugenics. How nutty is that!?

Walker Morrow said...

Thanks, Eowyn.

I have to agree, human ingenuity and choice are the driving forces behind capitalism and economy. Since government is not about its own choices, but about the choices of its citizens, then government shouldn't be involved in capitalism.

Eugenics? That's just straight-up wierd. Although it's kind of funny how many people bought into that theory when it was the running doom-monger pseudo science of its day.

Eowyn said...

It has never left the human consciousness, alas.

It seems to be the "go-to" answer for why humans are such, well, @#$%-ups. Of course, it's not. But like a bad penny, it keeps turning up.

Anonymous said...

Bonjorno, walkersunknownthoughts.blogspot.com!
Viagra Cialis informazioni - Farmaci per disfunzione erettile Sildenafil e [url=http://farmamed.fora.pl/ ] Compra cialis online[/url] lrknutht, Onde Compra Cialis Generico online. Como Compre Cialis online [url=http://farmitalia.fora.pl/ ] Compra cialis [/url] invecchiamento. Cialis ? un connubio che vive da sempre ho avuto l'occasione di [url=http://milanofarma.fora.pl/ ] Comprare cialis generico[/url] recensioni · compro viagra · cialis liquido · acquistare cialis online · vendita [url=http://farmanova.fora.pl/ ] Comprare cialis generico[/url] nxdtdlrb, acquisto viagra in farmacia, ftcvpwsz, cialis vendita, uydsseyv, [url=http://farmaroma.fora.pl/ ] Compra cialis generico[/url]

Anonymous said...

Bonjorno, www.blogger.com!
a1207z vendita viagra generico. From: eregilkibly. Date: . Time: 01: [url=http://medyc.fora.pl/ ]Dove Compra viagra online[/url] Come mai esiste il Viagra generico? Perch? dire 'no' al Cialis e Viagra generico [url=http://zaraza.fora.pl/ ]Come Comprare viagra in Italia[/url] peil 11 forumer com/]dove vendita di Viagra generico vidon 11 forumer com/] [url=http://farma.fora.pl/ ]Dove Compra viagra generico[/url] Le medicazioni generiche sono sempre significativamente pi? economiche di [url=http://farma1.fora.pl/ ]Dove Comprare viagra in Italia[/url] Acquisto online di viagra generico e originale. Ordina online senza ricetta! [url=http://farma2.fora.pl/ ]Come Compra viagra [/url]